PR29 – stopgap or stepchange?

Ministers at Defra and water regulators want the next price review to be 'different'. Utility Week speaks to the chair of British Water, a Conservative peer and water industry experts to find out how it is shaping up.

By Ella Jessel, water editor

PR29 – stopgap or stepchange?

Ministers at Defra and water regulators want the next price review to be 'different'. Utility Week speaks to the chair of British Water, a Conservative peer and water industry experts to find out how it is shaping up.

By Ella Jessel, water editor

The water sector’s next price review has only just kicked off but is already being touted as mould-breaking. Water minister Emma Hardy has been clear with the industry that PR29 needs to be “different to what came before”. Meanwhile, Environment secretary Angela Eagle has warned she does not want to see “business as usual”.

Some early thinking is emerging on what this could mean. This month, Ofwat, the Drinking Water Inspectorate, the Environment Agency and Natural England jointly published their top-level steer for a “joined-up” price control. Its main thrust is a longer-term lens, with a bigger emphasis on grassroots priorities and the beginnings of a move towards the new supervisory approach. It will also be run differently. Rather than being led by Ofwat alone, the water regulators will plan for the price review together – and have been instructed by ministers to “act as one”.

But there is scepticism over how this joined-up approach will play out, and uncertainty over how the next five years will be shaped by the government’s 10-year-plan, due before Christmas.

Hardy said last week that the government would not consult on strategic guidance until next spring. This is a “key missing ingredient”, says Enrico Russo, a principal in consultancy Oxera’s regulation team. He adds: “This will be crucial to understanding whether PR29 resolves these trade-offs differently from past reviews.”

‘Fragmented’ approach

The joint regulators insist that PR29 will be “collaborative”, but planning for the price review while merging regulators will be no mean feat. Conservative peer Baroness McIntosh of Pickering, an environmental specialist and former shadow environment minister, tells Utility Week that while the aim is greater coordination, it could have the “reverse effect”.

“Rather than the current situation where an independent regulator sets the parameters for the pricing review, it could lead to a very fragmented approach,” she says.

The most recent price review, PR24, was defined by record spending package of £104 billion investment by water firms, with environmental improvement one of its main goals. This has resulted in bills rising – a break from the primary focus on affordability that characterised previous cycles.

So far, it’s not clear whether the next price control will try to go beyond this. “There is no talk of increased investment at this stage so [it] fails to address the desperate need to address the issue of billions of leakages in water through Victorian-age pipe,” says McIntosh.

“The UK is not unique in facing this challenge but given the age and the length of the pipes, replacing them in England is a mammoth and expensive task. Changing the way decisions are taken will not increase the amount of funding available to invest in and improve the system.”

Martin Hurst, an associate at policy think-tank Sustainability First and former water director at the Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), sees “much to welcome” in the joint regulators’ statement. However, he caveats that there are a number of “key tests” for PR29. “It must not be a holding operation but genuinely forward-looking,” he says. “It must be simpler and be much more transparent for customers; and it must rebalance away from costly and inefficient process regulation towards outcomes.”

Hurst adds that the business planning framework must align with the new regional approach, and should take on board and incentivise developments on machine learning and nature based approaches as they arise rather than a “rigid once-every-five-year determination”.


“The UK is not unique in facing this challenge but given the age and the length of the pipes, replacing them in England is a mammoth and expensive task.”

Baroness McIntosh of Pickering


Ending ‘boom and bust’

Hardy told the Chartered Institution of Water Environment Management (CIWEM) conference this month that she wanted an end to the “five-year cycle of boom-bust, boom-bust” that has defined previous price reviews. “I don’t think anyone thinks it is an effective way of doing it,” she added.

PR29 will still run for five years but will place “greater emphasis on long-term outcomes”. This means companies will need to show how five-year plans contribute to investment pathways over 10 and 25 years, according to the joint regulators’ document.

Stephen Slessor, chair at British Water, the trade body representing the water supply chain, picked this out as “the most important signal in the document”, because continuity is what allows delivery partners to invest in people, skills and manufacturing capacity in the UK. “The commitment to test whether plans can be delivered is also the right one,” he adds. “If PR29 is to avoid another stop-start investment cycle between AMP8 and AMP9, the people who design, build and maintain the assets need to be in the room from January, not consulted once plans are written.”

Echoing this, Adam Young, nature policy officer at think-tank the Aldersgate Group, also welcomed the plan for PR29 to be designed around long-term outcomes. “Water companies and their supply chains need this certainty to plan and invest with confidence,” he says.

A greater focus on local priorities will be another characteristic of PR29. The eight regional water councils confirmed recently by the government will play a role. The councils, on which water companies will not be given an automatic seat, are expected to produce their first draft plans by next summer.

In a letter sent to mayors and local political leaders, Eagle said the water councils will influence the next round of water industry planning, adding: “For the first time since privatisation, investment decisions through the next investment period will be shaped much more directly by the priorities of local communities, regional leaders and those who understand the needs of places best.”

Water companies have long asked customers for their views, but the “game changer” for PR 29 will be that they will have to show how local, regional and catchment priorities have shaped their plans, according to Lucy James, managing director at stakeholder engagement consultancy EQ Communications,

This will now be enforceable for the first time under Ofwat’s Customer Involvement Rule, which came into effect earlier this year and requires firms to actively involve consumers in material business decisions.

From a stakeholder perspective, the biggest shift will be the place-based approach. “This means involving local authorities, catchment partnerships and other local stakeholders in a way we haven’t seen before,” she says.

However, James warns that the timetable for water companies is “tighter than it looks”, and for stakeholders to genuinely shape emerging thinking, work needs to start now. “Bottom-up only works if people can see their input made a difference,” she adds. “Companies need to close the loop and show stakeholders how their feedback changed decisions.”


“Bottom-up only works if people can see their input made a difference. Companies need to close the loop and show stakeholders how their feedback changed decisions.”

Lucy James, managing director, EQ Communications

Fair shot for nature-based solutions

Options such as nature-based solutions could also get a better hearing in the new-look price control. The regulators said water firms will need to consider whether lower cost, collaborative, nature-based or more flexible approaches could deliver the required outcomes. “We are particularly pleased to see nature-based solutions considered alongside traditional infrastructure,” says Young. “Ofwat’s leaning towards more outcome-based investment sign-off should help these solutions compete on a level playing field.”

Yet Cat Moncreiff, policy manager at CIWEM, cautions that PR29 will need to provide “strong incentives” to drive the needed investment in nature-based, catchment resilience measures and pollution prevention at source rather than costly end-of-pipe treatment.

“While the increased emphasis on local and catchment evidence is very welcome, greater clarity is needed on how PR29 will align with the emerging regional planning framework proposed in the Water White Paper,” she adds.

Russo says PR29 will be a transitional price review, and its framework will need to be flexible enough to accommodate changes in policy.

He also points out companies will need clarity in the coming months on how supervision will be applied in practice. “For example, will regulators start from benchmarking evidence and adjust it based on supervisory insights, or will benchmarking be used to challenge supervisory decisions?”

He adds: “What really matters is that action on key areas, like investing in asset health, is not delayed to PR34.”