Leader


James Wallin, editor in chief

For PR29 to be truly different, someone has to own the trade-offs

We’ve been here before. But this time it’ll be different, it really will.

Our cover feature this week explores the building blocks of the next price control for water. PR29 will mark the start of a new decade but will it also herald a new dawn?

It’s almost five years since Utility Week and PA Consulting produced a report at this stage of the PR24 process. That carried the industry view that 2025-30 would be a transitional period, building towards a generational shift in water regulation. It’s important not to overlook the shift that PR24 represented in terms of investment, protection of the environment and the approach to bills.

However, fundamentally this process used the same toolkit of cost-plus regulation pioneered by Stephen Littlechild at the dawn of utilities privatisation. It was made clear on all sides at the end of that process that a different set of tools would be needed to fix the problems facing the water sector.

As explored overleaf, the regulators' joint Working Together to Deliver PR29 publication aims to open a new chapter. This short report is inevitably high level but makes some encouraging points around moving towards a longer-term, more supervisory and transparent price control process. All of these aims are as laudable as they are fiendishly difficult to put into practice.

Crucially, this is also a “joined up” approach across all of the regulators. And this is where we get on to my hobbyhorse of trade-offs. I’ve written before about my scepticism that the often conflicting responsibilities of all the existing water regulators can be accommodated in a single body without compromises. I accept that compromise doesn’t have to be a dirty word but surely we could all agree that things like drinking water quality standards must remain sacrosanct.

Then of course there is the issue of affordability. How can we even start to plan PR29 without any serious conversation about how much it is going to cost? A price control that steps out from behind the spreadsheet and addresses the particular circumstances of each company and each local area clearly sounds like the right approach. But I’ve yet to meet anyone who can tell me how much a truly supervisory approach to regulation could cost. In fact, one of the issues I’ve started to encounter is that supervisory regulation seems to be mean quite different things to different people.

When we published the aforementioned report in January 2022, attendees at the launch roundtable pessimistically told us it was “too late for PR24”. By this they meant it would not provide the step change the industry needed. It is certainly not too late for PR29 but for it to be truly different, the government needs to quickly get a handle on the trade-offs facing the sector and make some tough choices.

These issues will be explored in more detail across various sessions at Utility Week Forum next week. Standard tickets are now sold out but there are still a few places left for utilities. Register your interest here.

Top stories on Utility Week

EDF seals deal to buy Utilita

Mayors to get powers to ‘summon’ water companies and make them share data

Energy minister calls out Ofgem’s ‘failure’ in auditing ECO4 scheme

We are ‘falling behind’ on net zero, does this increase gas grid’s value?

Bonus ban review: Ofwat mulls ‘different’ rules for poor performing firms

For PR29 to be truly different, someone has to own the trade-offs

We’ve been here before. But this time it’ll be different, it really will.

Our cover feature this week explores the building blocks of the next price control for water. PR29 will mark the start of a new decade but will it also herald a new dawn?

It’s almost five years since Utility Week and PA Consulting produced a report at this stage of the PR24 process. That carried the industry view that 2025-30 would be a transitional period, building towards a generational shift in water regulation. It’s important not to overlook the shift that PR24 represented in terms of investment, protection of the environment and the approach to bills.

However, fundamentally this process used the same toolkit of cost-plus regulation pioneered by Stephen Littlechild at the dawn of utilities privatisation. It was made clear on all sides at the end of that process that a different set of tools would be needed to fix the problems facing the water sector.

As explored overleaf, the regulators' joint Working Together to Deliver PR29 publication aims to open a new chapter. This short report is inevitably high level but makes some encouraging points around moving towards a longer-term, more supervisory and transparent price control process. All of these aims are as laudable as they are fiendishly difficult to put into practice.

Crucially, this is also a “joined up” approach across all of the regulators. And this is where we get on to my hobbyhorse of trade-offs. I’ve written before about my scepticism that the often conflicting responsibilities of all the existing water regulators can be accommodated in a single body without compromises. I accept that compromise doesn’t have to be a dirty word but surely we could all agree that things like drinking water quality standards must remain sacrosanct.

Then of course there is the issue of affordability. How can we even start to plan PR29 without any serious conversation about how much it is going to cost? A price control that steps out from behind the spreadsheet and addresses the particular circumstances of each company and each local area clearly sounds like the right approach. But I’ve yet to meet anyone who can tell me how much a truly supervisory approach to regulation could cost. In fact, one of the issues I’ve started to encounter is that supervisory regulation seems to be mean quite different things to different people.

When we published the aforementioned report in January 2022, attendees at the launch roundtable pessimistically told us it was “too late for PR24”. By this they meant it would not provide the step change the industry needed. It is certainly not too late for PR29 but for it to be truly different, the government needs to quickly get a handle on the trade-offs facing the sector and make some tough choices.

These issues will be explored in more detail across various sessions at Utility Week Forum next week. Standard tickets are now sold out but there are still a few places left for utilities. Register your interest here.

Top stories on Utility Week

EDF seals deal to buy Utilita

Mayors to get powers to ‘summon’ water companies and make them share data

Energy minister calls out Ofgem’s ‘failure’ in auditing ECO4 scheme

We are ‘falling behind’ on net zero, does this increase gas grid’s value?

Bonus ban review: Ofwat mulls ‘different’ rules for poor performing firms