History lessons for Treasury’s bills cuts plan

The Treasury is reviving an idea from the coalition years to put a lid on the policy costs added to bills. But wholesale and network costs are largely beyond its reach, so experts warn it won’t spare the chancellor some hard choices.

By David Blackman, policy correspondent

History lessons for Treasury’s bills cuts plan

The Treasury is reviving an idea from the coalition years to put a lid on the policy costs added to bills. But wholesale and network costs are largely beyond its reach, so experts warn it won’t spare the chancellor some hard choices.

By David Blackman, policy correspondent

George Osborne has never had a great press in the Labour Party. Its members still regularly hiss about the pernicious effects of the austerity programme the ex-chancellor of the exchequer introduced during the early 2010s. However, one Osborne-era Treasury initiative looks set for a fresh lease of life.

Next year’s pan-government spending review is due to see the introduction of a new Cost Control Framework (CCF) for energy bills, Osborne’s successor-but-seven John Healey announced in last month’s Budget. The title sounds suspiciously like the Levy Control Framework (LCF), which was introduced by Osborne’s Treasury in 2010 to cap energy policy costs.

It is thought that one of the principle aims of the mechanism was to check the work of the energy department, which was run by a Liberal Democrat secretary of state during the coalition government. However, it was also a response to the ballooning costs of the Renewables Obligation (RO) and Feed in Tariff (FiT), the first wave of low-carbon electricity generation subsidies introduced by Ed Miliband during his first spell as energy secretary in the late noughties.

During this period, levies grew “very quickly”, says Andrew Sissons, director in sustainable future at innovation charity Nesta. “It was getting very expensive.”

The LCF ended in 2017. Ben Westerman, director of policy and advocacy at the Electrify Britain campaign, says that levies had dropped down the agenda as the auction prices achieved for offshore wind projects plunged during successive Contracts for Difference (CfD) auctions. But that changed “dramatically” following 2023’s fifth auction round (AR5), which saw no successful bids for offshore wind projects, since when the costs of delivering these projects has “skyrocketed”, he says.

Meanwhile, the past five years have seen new levies either introduced or proposed on bills via the back door to pay for a plethora of energy system upgrades. With predictions this week that energy bills are set to rocket by as much as 26% in the new year, it is clear the government needs to pull a rabbit out of the hat. Could the CCF do the trick?

Scrutiny on costs is overdue

“It is a good thing that the government wants to control costs on bills, particularly thinking about how we pay for the energy system and trying to make sure that we're as progressive as possible so that lowest-income households aren't disproportionately paying,” says a fuel poverty source. “It seems like a good idea to put some control on that.

“Energy bills are now so political so you would want control of them to be as near to the centre of government as possible.”

Ned Hammond, deputy director of policy for customers at Energy UK, hopes the introduction of the CCF will mean greater scrutiny over new energy costs. He points out that having these costs directly on the government’s books is likely to signal an end to the current ad hoc approach.

Increases in costs for the Warm Homes Discount (WHD), the nuclear Regulated Asset Base subsidies and the RIIO3 transmission network price control have all been introduced at short notice, creating substantial headaches for suppliers, he says: “That not only creates significant financial risk for energy suppliers but also means that it's a higher cost for customers because that additional financial risk has got to be baked into the offers that they provide to customers.”

Successful delivery of the CCF will partly depend on learning the lessons from how the LCF panned out in the 2010s, says Arjan Geveke, director of the Energy Intensive User Group (EIUG), who was then a civil servant at the Department of Energy and Climate Change. The problem with the LCF was that while Treasury civil servants saw the annual figure as a cap on spending, their energy department colleagues saw it as a target, he says. This led to successive overspends, which led to the scheme’s abandonment in 2017.

Another flaw with the design was that the Treasury lacked sanctions to enforce its caps, such as having the power to cut the energy department budgets, Geveke says. But acknowledging that such sanctions would be “crude” and cause “absolute havoc” in the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, he says the Treasury is more likely to use the standard controls it has over departmental spending via the upcoming spending review process.

A big difference between the CCF and its near namesake predecessor scheme is that it looks set to be more wide-ranging. Details are scant in the Treasury’s Budget document about how the CCF will work but it says it will be “comprehensive” and set budgets for the “components” of energy bills, including policy costs.

The ability of the CCF to control costs will be limited though, says Hammond, who points out that wholesale energy costs cannot be controlled by the government, while those for supplier operation are already under the price cap regime.

Grid costs likely to stay off bills

Network costs, another big driver of bills but outside of the scope of the LCF, are likely to be under the microscope of the new regime. But while the scale of this investment is currently under debate, there is a widespread recognition that the bulk of it will be needed.

It also seems unlikely the government will be itching to take these costs on. A senior network source says: "There's clearly a conversation to be had with government about what can come off the bill and into general taxation. That's very, very welcome but the reality is there isn't the scope to take absorb huge volumes of cost on to the government's balance sheet.

"So, I don't see any world in which network costs don't sit on the bill, but it's about how you move those costs around.”

Agreeing, Westerman says: “Maybe [government] could take a small chunk, but there's no realistic pathway to government taking networks into exchequer spend.”

The senior network source adds that progress on any overhaul of the existing costs is likely to be “pretty high level” by next year’s Spending Review.

Greater government involvement in network spending could risk stepping on the toes of Ofgem’s regulation of price controls, says the fuel poverty source. This means the CCF’s focus is likely to be once again on policy costs and taxes, like the Climate Change Levy, says Hammond.

Until the new framework is in place, the Budget documents say no further policy costs will be added unless they reduce bills or are “essential” for security of supply. The Gas Shipper Obligation tax, which was due to support hydrogen projects, will not now be imposed as planned on gas bills, becoming the first casualty of the government‘s drive to tackle levies.

Support for carbon capture and storage (CCS) and hydrogen projects is clearly “vulnerable”, says Sissons.

There must be a question mark over why domestic consumers should pay for the industrial decarbonisation that support for CCS will primarily deliver, says Westerman: “That is about £15 billion in entirety and the benefit to the bill payer is around two to three pounds a year. You'd be spending an extortionate amount of government money to see very, very little political gain.”

It would make more sense for these kinds of projects be directly subsidised by government until they are more mature and less costly, says Jonny Marshall, a principal economist at the Resolution Foundation economics thinktank. “That's the time when they can transition into something that then is being paid for through electricity bills,” he adds.

And while existing nuclear levy commitments are likely to be safe, the CCF process could spark questions over support for the sector beyond Sizewell C, says Sissons.

He adds that one of the big three big policy costs, the WHD, is extremely unlikely to face the chop because it helps the poorest in society. Ditto the FiTs and ROs because the sums they cost are effectively winding down over the next few years.

Mixed picture for renewables

As was discussed in last week’s edition, the recent rise in costs for CfDs is likely to come under the CCF’s microscope. Some new offshore wind contracts may not pass the government’s new test that projects should reduce bills sets once their system costs are taken into account, says Sissons.

There are likely to be most nerves surrounding the prospects for floating offshore wind and tidal projects which are both at a relatively early and expensive stage of development, he says. However Sissons says he would be “very surprised” if the relatively cheaper solar and onshore wind fail to pass any affordability test.

And while CfD projects will sometimes get higher prices than those available on the wholesale markets, at other times these contracts will be paying back, as has been seen under the knock-on impact of gas prices, Marshall points out.

The CCF may also help the Treasury to achieve greater value for money from new CfDs as the government moves away from the current system of “blind” auctions to a more spatially planned approach, lessening the competitive pressure on developers with projects in locations identified for generation. “Having some sort of limit on the prices, you can produce the system that the government wants but with some lid on costs,” Marshall says.

The Treasury should not be too zealous about bearing down on levies though, says Sissons: “The problem might come if it's applied too crudely and we end up effectively saying ‘no more levies for anything’.

“If you then end up cutting off critical activities, you might have a problem because often levies can be expensive but they can also fund critical things that ultimately help to reduce bills or contribute to security of supply.”

There are risks that greater political scrutiny of energy costs could breed the kind of short-term decision making that has led to the network constraints currently bedevilling the network, says Hammond: “You don't want to end up in a situation where that is so politicised that you're making a decision, which is arguably what has happened with some of the network costs in the past, where preventing cost for the next couple of years has been over and above making sure the system is more cost-efficient in the future, which has led us to the situation we're in at the moment.

“There's obviously a risk that goes too far and no investments are being supported,” he says, adding that the new CCF must incorporate a sufficiently longer-term horizon that considers not just current customers but future ones as well.

The CCF may prove more durable than previous attempts to control energy bill costs, given the government’s focus on energy costs for both domestic and non-domestic customers, Hammond adds.

“This feels like a core part of how they aim to drive down electricity prices over the next few years,” he says. “Hopefully that means it is more successful.”

Removing the levies means there would no need for a control mechanism, Geveke says.

The existence of the CCF process won’t provide the government with a way out of making hard choices about energy costs, says the fuel poverty source: “It's really difficult to see without spending Treasury money how the government can use that cost control framework to reduce the costs.”

Agreeing, Westerman says Healey is probably now in a worse fiscal position than his recent predecessors as chancellor.

“He's still got to find the money from somewhere, while also paying for the NHS and defence,” he says. “That is a nasty political proposition and that's the situation in which we find ourselves.”


“[Healey] has got to find the money from somewhere, while also paying for the NHS and defence. That is a nasty political proposition and that’s the situation in which we find ourselves.”

Ben Westerman, director of policy and advocacy, Electrify Britain campaign